Strained Indo-Pak Ties To Stay (Opinion)

Strained Indo-Pak ties to stay (Opinion)

By Asad Mirza
India taking down Pakistan at the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meet is indicative of changing diplomatic might of India.India will not stick to fake goody words any longer.

 Strained Indo-pak Ties To Stay (opinion)

It signals Pakistan about the need to do more to shed the tag of being a global headache on terrorism.

Coming soon after the recent Shanghai Cooperation Council’s (SCO) Defence Ministers’ Summit in New Delhi, India last week hosted the Foreign Ministers of the SCO at Goa.

The common thread between these two summits was the tough posturing by India against its two neighbours Pakistan and China.

At the Goa meeting, India’s External Affairs Minister (EAM), S.Jaishankar, revealed that
India had twice called out China and Pakistan at the summit for violating India’s
sovereignty through their connectivity projects.

The statement was made in response to a question on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), which runs through Indian territory currently under Pakistan’s illegal occupation.

Earlier, India had sort of reprimanded the Chinese Defence Minister Li Shangfu at the New Delhi meeting, on the issue of the stalled talks over the Line of Actual Control

India’s critique of Pakistan

Pakistan’s Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari was in Goa to represent Pakistan at the SCO-CFM.A visit, which happened after a 12-year gap.

The last Pakistani Foreign Minister to visit India was Hina Rabbani Khar, when she met
her Indian counterpart S.M.Krishna in Delhi in 2011.

However, what soured the atmosphere this time in Goa, was references made by
Zardari over Kashmir and Pakistan being a victim of terrorism itself.Though he
also called for reviving the stalled talks.

India, in a strongly worded response to Pakistan’s overtures for talks, said
victims of terrorism do not sit together with perpetrators of terrorism to discuss

Rebutting each of the points made by Zardari, EAM Jaishankar said he (Zardari)
was “a promoter, justifier and spokesperson for a terrorism industry which is the
mainstay of Pakistan.

The tough Indian response came after the news of death of
five Indian Army soldiers in a terrorist attack near the Line of Control (LoC) on

Jaishankar said Bilawal’s suggestion to sit together and talk was “hypocritical” and said India was feeling “outraged” by the incident.

India’s stand on China

Jaishankar had a similar position on China whose readout on the bilateral
between him and its Foreign Minister Qin Gang described the situation on the boundary as stable.

Jaishankar said that there is an abnormal position in the border areas.”We
have to take the disengagement process forward.I have made it very clear.India-
China relations will not be normal if peace and tranquillity in the border areas is
disturbed.This message was on the same lines as delivered by the Indian
Defence Minister Rajnath Singh to his Chinese counterpart Li Shangfu, a fortnight ago.”

Responding to Zardari’s diatribe, Jaishankar said Bilawal’s opposition to a G-20
meeting to be held in Kashmir had no basis since Pakistan was not even a
member of that grouping.

On Bilawal’s opening address at the SCO conference where he said the issue of terrorism should not be used to score diplomatic points, the Minister said: “We are not scoring diplomatic points.We are exposing Pakistan.As a victim of terrorism, we are authorised to do so.We have put up with it.It speaks so much about the mindset of that country.”

He asked Pakistan to “smell the coffee” regarding its grouse about the abrogation
of Article 370 as a violation of international agreements.

“370 is history.Sooner the people realise it, the better,” Jaishankar said.

Indian response to CPEC

EAM Jaishankar also took an exception at the mention of CPEC at the SCO meeting, both by Pakistan and China.

And rightly so, as SCO is a multilateral forum, not a bilateral one and further India’s adversarial stand on the CPEC has been very clear from the beginning, as it passed through the PoK.India has consistently opposed the Belt and Road Initiative and CPEC, as these projects violate India’s territorial integrity and

Jaishankar very clearly stated that connectivity is good for progress, but
connectivity cannot violate the sovereignty and territorial integrity of nations.

Bilawal’s overture

On his part Bilawal Bhutto Zardari blamed India’s Kashmir policy for the “frozen
peace” between India and Pakistan.The India-Pakistan relationship soured significantly after India announced the withdrawal of special powers from Jammu and Kashmir and the division of the state into two union territories in August 2019.

India has always maintained that it wants regular neighbourly ties with Pakistan
while emphasising that the onus is on Islamabad to create a safe environment for
such an engagement.

The tough Indian response to both Pakistan and China, mainly stems from its
exhaustion with its neighbours, who in spite of several Indian initiatives to better
relations, prefer to stick with their age-old stands on the contentious issues,
preferring not to respond positively to any Indian efforts in this regard.

The SCO meet also showed yet again that body language speaks volumes in
geopolitics and diplomacy.

The distance between the two foreign ministers while
posing for photographs was noticeably gaping.However, the cold Indian
demeanour, a departure from customary diplomatic niceties, and continuing
with its old parroting by the Pakistani Minister were more targeted at their
respective domestic audiences.

The Indian leadership in view of the forthcoming elections in Karnataka wanted
to be seen as acting tough, while the Pakistani Minister wanted to showcase his
ability to rake-up old issues in the backdrop of the economic woes of Pakistan.
But overall this posturing does not augurs well for friendly relations between the
neighbours in the foreseeable future.

(Asad Mirza is a senior political commentator based in New Delhi.He can be contacted at


#IndoPak #stay #Delhi # Rajnath Singh #Jaishankar #Shankar #Krishna # Jaishankar #Krishna #China #Delhi #New Delhi #Goa #Jammu And Kashmir #Jammu #Karnataka